Beyond Checklists: Building a Best-of-Breed PCI Compliance Strategy
Finn Rafter-Phillips, Global Channel Manager, IPI
PCI DSS isn't just a hurdle to clear – it’s the foundation of customer trust. Organizations have previously approached PCI compliance as a set of checkboxes to tick off during annual assessments. But achieving true compliance, the kind that genuinely minimizes risk and builds long-term resilience, requires more than a minimum-effort approach. It demands a proactive, strategic mindset embedded across the entire business.
The reality is that data breaches are still making headlines, potentially eroding consumer trust for organizations. With customer loyalty hinging on trust, doing the bare minimum simply doesn’t cut it. The solution? Building a best-of-breed PCI strategy.
Organizations ultimately need to build a compliance strategy that not only meets today’s standards but also actively anticipates tomorrow’s challenges. This article explores how leading organizations are shifting from checkbox compliance to a risk-informed strategy, and the key pillars that define a more effective, resilient approach to PCI DSS.
The Stark Reality of Non-Compliance
The cost of falling short on PCI compliance continues to climb. IBM’s latest Cost of a Data Breach report estimates the global average cost of a breach now exceeds $4.88 million. While not every incident stems directly from PCI DSS violations, a significant proportion can be traced back to failures in protecting payment data.
These breaches aren’t just a financial issue. The reputational impact can be devastating. Studies show that over 70 percent of consumers are more likely to take their money elsewhere after their data has been compromised. The damage to trust, loyalty, and long-term customer relationships is often far greater than the immediate remediation costs.
Customers today now expect their payment details to be handled with absolute care. Failing to meet that expectation, even once, can lead to long-lasting consequences.
So, what separates basic PCI compliance from a best-in-breed strategy?
Moving from Minimum to Best-of-Breed
Below are five key pillars of a best-in-breed PCI compliance strategy, all of which reflect the growing shift toward more integrated, automated, and risk-based approaches.
1. Prioritize Data Minimization
The most effective way to protect customer data is to avoid collecting it in the first place. Leading organizations are adopting a “less is more” approach to payment data, ensuring they only store what’s absolutely necessary, thereby eliminating unnecessary risk in the process.
Data minimization can take many forms: designing workflows that bypass agent exposure to card data, using technologies that isolate payment entry points or fully outsourcing payment handling to PCI-certified third parties.
Tokenization and point-to-point encryption (P2PE) also play a vital role here. These tools convert sensitive data into unusable formats, making it meaningless to attackers even if it’s intercepted. These technologies are essential components of any serious compliance effort.
2. Embrace Continuous Monitoring
Annual audits or point-in-time assessments are no longer enough. With threats evolving in real time, compliance requires a continuous, always-on approach.
Organizations that excel in PCI DSS readiness use security monitoring tools that provide real-time visibility into their systems and environments. Solutions like Security Information and Event Management (SIEM) platforms and Intrusion Detection and Prevention Systems (IDS/IPS) help detect anomalies early, giving teams a chance to respond before damage is done.
The ability to continuously monitor for vulnerabilities or unauthorized access attempts isn’t just good practice – it’s becoming a regulatory expectation.
3. Foster a Culture of Security
Compliance is not just an IT responsibility. It’s a shared accountability that extends across departments and roles - from Contact Center agents to senior leadership.
Building a culture of security starts with education. Regular training programs help employees understand not only what the PCI DSS rules are, but why they matter. Simulated phishing exercises, security awareness workshops and real-world case studies can all help reinforce the importance of vigilance in everyday workflows.
Employees are often the first line of defense. Ensuring they have the awareness and tools to uphold compliance in their roles is key for long-term success.
4. Leverage Automation to Strengthen Compliance
Manual compliance processes are notoriously error-prone. Whether it's forgetting a step in a payment workflow or delaying a critical software update, relying on human intervention introduces unnecessary risk.
Forward-thinking organizations are turning to automation when it comes to their compliance strategies. Automated vulnerability scanning ensures that systems are continually checked for weaknesses, while patch management tools help apply security updates consistently and without delay.
By removing the burden of routine compliance tasks from human hands, businesses not only improve accuracy but also free up teams to focus on higher-value work. In today’s fast-moving threat landscape, automation isn’t a nice-to-have - it’s essential to staying compliant and secure.
5. Adopt a Zero Trust Approach
In a time when insider threats, credential theft, and remote work are all on the rise, the Zero Trust security model, built on the principle of “never trust, always verify” is becoming increasingly popular for organizations.
Under a Zero Trust approach, no user or device is automatically trusted, even if they’re inside the network perimeter. Instead, access is granted based on continuous verification of identity, context and security posture.
For organizations aiming to maintain PCI DSS compliance, this model provides a structured way to ensure only authorized users can access cardholder data environments. It strengthens control over who can do what, from where, and when - making it significantly harder for malicious actors.
The Strategic Advantage
Gartner predicts that more than 60 percent of organizations will use risk-based security assessments to drive compliance decisions. This shift reflects a growing realization that security and compliance must evolve together - not in parallel.
By building a strategy rooted in visibility, automation and cross-functional collaboration, organizations reduce the risk of breaches, streamline compliance efforts, and improve operational efficiency. They also stand to gain something harder to measure, but just as critical: customer trust.
In short, a best-in-breed PCI compliance strategy isn’t just about satisfying regulators – it’s a business advantage. Organizations that get it right can expect:
- A significantly reduced risk of data breaches and security incidents
- Stronger customer trust, loyalty, and confidence in digital transactions
- Lower operational costs through streamlined, automated compliance processes
- A stronger, more resilient brand reputation in a competitive market
Organizations mustn’t settle for the minimum. They must strive for a strategy that not only meets PCI DSS standards, but exceeds them, by building a true compliance fortress that protects their business and their customers.
Also, view the June 2025 Newsletter Here!